About How they
Make music

  by Dominic Vautier
6/2012


Cartridges consist of two parts, the stylus itself and the magnets.  The motion of the stylus induces a very small current flow in the magnetic coils which are then electronically translated into wave pattern. The stylus is a box-shaped shell which has a small delicate arm with a diamond needle attached to one end and a small dollop of magnetic material on the other end.  This arm is expected to move small distances at up to 22,000 Hz.  When you think about it, this is really really really fast.  Modern diamond stylus tips are usually conical or elliptical to follow the grooves better since the stylus is never at right angles to the groove except at the middle of the record. I did some more on record cartridges here

 

MATERIAL

Vinyl is pliable--kind of like rubber.  Every time a stylus passes through those intricate grooves it deforms them just a bit.  But very soon, often within split seconds, the grooves go perfectly back to their original shape unless they are deformed too much.  That’s what happens when an LP record is played with less expensive record players or at excessive stylus pressure which could generate permanent groove deformation. Other things determine quality but the condition of the record is quite important.

WIGGLES

Here is what an average record groove looks like before cleaning. There are several dust particles. There is also a lot of room between grooves thanks to RIAA and the cutting machine settings.

 

 

 

Here is a sample where the sound is soft and few wiggles are present.  The record was cleaned.  Notice the huge amount of space between grooves.

 

 

 

 

This shows a much more complex sound pattern. Yet there is still a lot of space between grooves.  Records can have 10 or 11 songs on a side but 5 or 6 is better because the groove can be the standard one mil.  If you put too many grooves they can't be as deep or as far apart. 

 

 

 

 

HOW MUCH

This compares two records.  the first had a running time of 18 minutes. There's a lot of free space between grooves.

 

 

 

 

The second had a run time of 29 minutes. There were no skips. Both were in excellent shape and sounded fine.

 

 

 

The amount of material on one side of an LP can be up to 30 minutes or 9 songs without loss of quality.  The standard of five songs per side is a marketing decision and not based on physical limitations of the record.  Buth this high density may cause tripping problems since many players require sufficuent dead wax to trip the unit into shutdown.

Return Distance on High Density records

If the playing time of an LP is around 30 minutes it does not necessarily mean poor quality but it does have less dead wax area and less time between songs.  On a normal record the dead wax begins at 1 15/16th inch from the center hole and goes to about 2 3/4 inches.  On high density records music may run as close as 2 3/8th from center.  End of record return tripping can occur before the end of the last song so either the player shuts down before the last song is done or it continues to skip back unable to overcome the slight force required to catch the return lever.  Ideal return position for a player is 2 1/4 inches from center but often this is not correct and not adjustable.  Players with auto-return are not able to handle high density records well.     

Buying Records

When I buy a used record at a second-hand store or garage sale I have absolutely no idea how well it plays because I can't see the wiggles, only scratches, fingerprints and hole ware.  Never mind the finger prints, beer stains, lipstick, gum, scratches and smudges.  Although these are often an indicator of overall record care, they can be removed.  A record may not even have a single scratch, which probably means that it’s in good shape.  But it may have been played just once on a bad machine that permanently deformed the high frequency wiggles and the record has a lot of permanent hiss.  Or the recording may be bad or there could be background hiss or rumble.  There could be poor separation.

If you digitize, smaller record scratches can be removed with filters and tools.  Small pops and snaps can be detected with the right software or removed manually without destroying too much if any of the signal.  A usual click is 1/1000 second at most.  Headroom is really what you want, that open sound of air and depth between 8000 and 12,000 KHz that can give much added presence to a record, and which is usually lacking in earlier music.  There is also a Psychoacoustics effects that are not within hearing range.  Some claim it effects the sound.

The “S” never lies  

Sometimes I look for clean “s” sounds because it can determine record condition right off.  It can also indicate the kind of treatment the record has been subjected to or even the quality of the  manufacturing or recording process.  The “s” never lies and is a good indicator.  It’s a sound component that actually goes way up above 10,000 KHz. I also try to judge a cartridge by the way it plays the “s” sound.  If the cartridge is tracking too lightly it can rattle around and produce a sloppy “sssshhh” sound instead of a clear "s".  If the cartridge is tracking badly or too little on the outside groove (skating pressure) , I will sometimes hear a sloppy “s” on the left channel.

Lazy tone arm 

I get the impression that record player companies got lazy and installed tone arm mounts too close to the platter.  This may have been done in order to keep record machines smaller and reduce shipping costs and also have them conform in size of other components on the market early in the hi-fi days, like pre-amps, amps, tape decks, and receivers.  This caused problems because in order to track the groove properly the tone arm had to overhang the turntable center which created an inward force that tended to pull the tone arm toward center.  This pressure increased as the tone arm got closer to the center.  If the force vector overcame the weight force that kept the stylus tracking then the result is“skating” where the entire tone arm decides to take a ride to the center of your LP.  Skating caused other problems too.  It forced the stylus to hug the inside of the groove and sometimes you got “chatter” on the left channel (outside groove).  Sometimes the left channel would sputter and click, all as result of bad contact with the outer groove wall.

Another thing about stylus tracking.  Study your cartridge and see how it tracks the record.  I have found that it is sometimes necessary to add small paper shims to the mount to get the stylus to track properly.  Over time and use the stylus could twist a bit or lose some of its shape.  The standard mount allows a good deal of cartridge rotation from side to side.  But if you want to make adjustments other ways you need shims.

   

This skating problem is not all that complicated.  A lot depends on the record itself so there is simply no hard and fast rule.  I have some records that just love to skate regardless of what I do. It may have to do with groove depth.  Apparently the record cutter did not cut deep enough or the stamper was at the end of its life.  If a record is well cut then it usually is good enough to hold the stylus with or without antiskating.  Sometimes a defect or scratch will throw the stylus out of the groove but it should bounce to the inner groove.  If it skates, increase your stylus pressure slightly and maybe increase the antiskating.  Usually the antiskating device corresponds to the stylus pressure which does not make a lot of sense to me.  The theory is that more stylus pressure creates more inward force, and therefore you need more outward force.  But increased stylus weight also will tend to keep the stylus in the groove.  Good records shouldn't need any antiskating if you track at enough weight.  If you track at less than a gram, it might skate. An older stylus should track better since it sits deeper in the groove but it will be noiser.      

Five songs or 18 minutes of playing time per side is just about standard.  This leaves a lot of wall between grooves and the grooves can be cut slightly deeper.  Some records try to cram 10 songs on a side but the grooves are quite close together and may not be as deep.  The sound quality may be poor on high density records, but not necessarially.

Wiggle Room

Another problem arose from tone arm overhang.  This could cause a round stylus not to follow both groove walls evenly near the record center where the wiggles get more compressed.  Look at a record and you will notice it has about two and a half times the room on the outside than it has on the inside which means the stylus travels two and a half times faster over the same time span of music. This means that the wiggles have to be that much tighter together on the inside.  So designers developed elliptical and conical styluses to help solve this problem.  Flattened cone shapes can track those compressed inside grooves better.


Clean as a whistle

I think audiophiles get way too preoccupied with cleaning records and exaggerate the anticipated improvement in sound quality.  I noticed that a few fingerprints on a record really do not seem to matter much because the oil is mostly on the top in the area between grooves and not in the groove itself and may not effect signal at all.  You have much more flat surface area than groove area. But if you really like cleaning records, you can use warm water and mild detergent or the many other devices on the market.  It will certainly get things cleaned up.  But dust will always happen.  And new dust comes back within minutes.  A record needs to be dusted immediately before every single play.  Those pictures taken above show that dust particles are everywhere.    

Hot water may warp a record but it will return to its original shape once it cools off.  Warm water is better.  Water and mild detergent removes fingerprints and just about anything else within reason but it can leave a residue.  I once got a record that had an iron left on it.  Not only was it badly warped. but the grooves were melted on part of the record.  I was able to save the inside part.

I did get some good feedback from Andy and he had some suggestions on record cleaning.  In his web page he says that the use of detergent is far better than hand soap which definitely leaves residue.

There is a possibility that fingerprint oil can collect on your stylus and then you have to be especially careful when cleaning a stylus.  I always dust off the record immediately before play while it is turning and before lowering my stylus.  I think that’s common practice anyway.  You don’t want to finish recording and find dust particles collected on the stylus.

 

LPs were probably the greatest thing that ever happened to the music industry and this same format was followed by the digital CD.  So why is it now disappearing?